Skip to content
Roofsmith Homepage

    The Ultimate Showdown for Your Home's Crown!

    By Mike Farist

    Metal Roofing vs. Asphalt Shingle Roofing: A Detailed Comparison

    Metal Roofing and Asphalt Shingle Roofing are two of the heavyweight contenders in this arena, each with its unique strengths and characteristics. Your roof isn't just a protective covering; it's a vital part of your home's identity. This showdown will help you make an informed decision about which one suits your home best.

    Round 1: Durability

    In one corner, weighing in with heavyweight durability, we've got Metal Roofing – a true titan when it comes to longevity. This shiny, unyielding material can take a punch from Mother Nature herself. Hail? Wind? No problem. It can withstand the harshest of weather conditions and has a lifespan that rivals Yoda's wisdom. Metal Roofing is by far the longevity winner.

    On the opposite side, is the crowd favorite, Asphalt Shingled Roofing. It may not be as tough as metal, but it still offers reliable protection with a lifespan of 20-30 years and has the charm of an old-school Hollywood star. It might require a bit more attention over the years, but it's a classic choice that has stood the test of time.

    Round 2: Aesthetics

    Metal roofing exudes sleek, modern sophistication, like the James Bond of roofing materials. It's the rooftop equivalent of a well-tailored suit – a suave, stylish appearance that’s sure to impress. But remember, aesthetics are subjective. The choice should align with your home's unique style and character.

    Asphalt Shingled Roofing, on the other hand, is throwing down some serious style game! With a vast array of colors, textures, and patterns, these shingles can match your home's vibe perfectly.

    Round 3: Maintenance

    Metal roofing is the epitome of low maintenance. Minimal attention? Check. Resistance to pests, rot, and the elements? Double-check. It's like the James Dean of the roofing world – effortlessly cool and not afraid to age gracefully. Regular maintenance is still essential to ensure its long-term performance.

    But don't underestimate Asphalt Shingled Roofing. It's low-maintenance, sure, but may require occasional attention to combat moss and algae action, adding a bit of drama for the curious observer.

    Round 4: Energy Efficiency

    Metal roofing reflects sunlight, keeping your home cooler and your energy bills in check. It's an energy-efficient choice that can help you stay comfortable in hot weather.

    Asphalt Shingle Roofing is no slouch either, with energy-efficient options that provide insulation to reduce your energy consumption.

    Round 5: Eco-Friendliness

    Metal roofing strides in, waving the eco-flag high. Made from recycled materials and fully recyclable itself, it's like the eco-warrior of roofing. Every roofing tile plays a part in reducing waste and environmental impact, making it a sustainable choice.

    Not to be outdone, Asphalt Shingled Roofing is catching up with recycling efforts to reduce its environmental impact and carbon footprint. Maybe a bit late to the game, but still making a valiant effort to contribute positively to the environment.

    Round 6: Installation

    Metal roofing makes its entrance with a flair for the dramatic. It's like a magician pulling off the ultimate trick – stunning, but you better have the right crew on hand because this contestant requires specialized skills and a professional crew for a flawless installation.

    And then we have Asphalt Shingled Roofing, the more DIY-friendly option. It's like that Pinterest project you tackled over the weekend – familiar, doable, and oh-so-satisfying when you're sipping lemonade on the newly roofed porch.

    Final Verdict: The Choice is Yours!

    In the end, the power lies in your hands, and each contender brings its own unique strengths and quirks to the table. Will you opt for the cutting-edge durability and modern allure of metal roofing? Or perhaps you'll embrace the timeless charm of asphalt shingles, a choice that's gentle on both your home and your wallet.

    The choice ultimately rests with you, and it should align with your personal style and preferences. Your roof is more than a mere covering; it's a declaration, a guardian, and a canvas for your individuality.

    Choosing the right roofing company is as vital as selecting the material itself. Look for experience, reliability, and stellar customer reviews. Ensure they use only the finest materials, and that they are at the forefront of industry knowledge and expertise. Your home deserves nothing less than the absolute best.

    So, as you make your choice, remember that your home is an extension of yourself. Make it a masterpiece, one roofing tile at a time, because in the world of roofing, every decision counts!